WASHINGTON — When Ted Cruz attended Harvard Legislation Faculty, he preferred to review with individuals who had undergraduate levels from Harvard, Yale or Princeton. “He mentioned he didn’t need anyone from ‘minor Ivies’ like Penn or Brown,” considered one of his legislation college roommates informed GQ.
That will strike you as slicing the baloney of elitism awfully skinny. However a brand new research has discovered that Supreme Courtroom justices do a lot the identical factor in choosing their legislation clerks.
It isn’t information that the justices favor a handful of legislation faculties in doling out clerkships, a glittering credential that each one however ensures success in a occupation obsessive about standing markers. However the research provides one other issue: To get a clerkship, it actually helps to have gone to varsity at Harvard, Yale or Princeton.
Albert Yoon, a legislation professor on the College of Toronto and one of many research’s authors, mentioned the discovering was disturbing.
“We don’t actually dwell in a meritocracy,” he mentioned. “The Supreme Courtroom is responsible of perpetuating among the worst pathologies in American society.”
Every justice sometimes hires 4 legislation clerks per time period. The research, which collected knowledge on the 1,426 former clerks within the 40-year interval ending in 2020, discovered that greater than two-thirds of them attended simply 5 legislation faculties: Harvard, Yale, Stanford, Columbia and the College of Chicago. Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr., as an illustration, selected 58 clerks within the interval lined by the research, 37 of them from Harvard or Yale.
You would possibly assume that doing properly at a kind of legislation faculties after which acquiring a prestigious clerkship with a federal appeals courtroom choose would verify the mandatory bins. But it surely seems that undergraduate levels appear to matter, too. Going to varsity at Harvard, Yale or Princeton — even after controlling for legislation college grades — gave candidates a major increase, the research discovered.
Perceive the U.S. Supreme Courtroom’s New Time period
Mr. Cruz, now a senator from Texas, could also be a living proof. He graduated with honors from Harvard Legislation Faculty and served as a legislation clerk to Choose J. Michael Luttig earlier than happening to clerk for Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist. And Mr. Cruz went to varsity at Princeton.
The research, carried out by Professor Yoon, Tracey E. George of Vanderbilt College and Mitu Gulati of the College of Virginia, targeted on Harvard Legislation Faculty. It has lengthy produced probably the most Supreme Courtroom legislation clerks, partly due to its status and partly as a result of it’s a lot bigger than a few of its rivals. (A bigger proportion of Yale Legislation Faculty graduates have served as Supreme Courtroom clerks.)
The research, which thought of 22,475 Harvard Legislation graduates, took account of three knowledge factors: the place they went to varsity, whether or not they certified for tutorial honors in legislation college (graduating cum laude, magna cum laude or summa cum laude) and whether or not they obtained a Supreme Courtroom clerkship.
About half of the graduates had attended considered one of 22 selective undergraduate establishments, and greater than a fifth of the graduates had gone to varsity at Harvard, Yale or Princeton. Each of these teams graduated with honors from Harvard Legislation at above-average charges.
However right here is the important thing level: Even controlling for achievement in legislation college as measured by educational honors, members of the 2 teams have been extra probably than their friends to acquire Supreme Courtroom clerkships. And a lot of the distinction might be traced to college students who had gone to varsity at Harvard, Yale or Princeton.
They have been 3 times extra more likely to get clerkships as those that had gone to the opposite 19 undergraduate establishments when graduating with cum laude honors and 50 p.c extra probably when graduating with magna cum laude honors. Each variations have been statistically vital. (Summa cum laude honors have been very uncommon and fairly often led to clerkships no matter undergraduate establishment.)
Extra on the U.S. Supreme Courtroom
The underside line, Professor George mentioned, is that the street to a Supreme Courtroom clerkship begins in faculty.
“Elite legislation college levels don’t restore or overcome a lower-status undergraduate diploma,” she mentioned. “You’ll be able to’t scrub your undergraduate diploma with a legislation diploma.”
Professor Gulati mentioned there’s something disturbing about this on condition that Supreme Courtroom clerkships are authorities jobs, and clerical ones at that.
“The method appears extremely biased towards elite non-public faculties,” he mentioned.
The issue, Professor Yoon mentioned, was not with the younger attorneys who made the minimize. “The individuals who get Supreme Courtroom clerkships are nice,” he mentioned. “However there are lots of nice individuals who don’t get it.”
The justices themselves are merchandise of elite educations. Eight of them attended legislation college at Harvard or Yale, and 6 of them have undergraduate levels from Harvard, Yale or Princeton. And 6 of them had themselves served as legislation clerks on the Supreme Courtroom.
There could be a clubby high quality to the justices’ remarks concerning the faculties they attended. Chief Justice Roberts, who has two Harvard levels, was requested in 2009 whether or not Supreme Courtroom justices “might relate to bizarre of us.”
The chief justice mentioned he wished to dispel a delusion. “Not all justices went to elite establishments,” he mentioned. “A few of them went to Yale.”
